1.1. According to the online dictionary, Wiktionary, industrialisation is a process of economic change whereby a human society is transformed from a pre-industrial to an industrial state. [Wiktionary, 2009, [O]]
Industrialisation could be seen as the rise of the working class, due to the introduction of machinery based factories. These led to higher productivity in the Secondary stage of production (manufacturing). Fritz Lang’s “Metropolis” and Dziga Vertov’s “The Man with the Movie Camera” are both centred on the theme of industrialisation. Both movies focus on the human classes created by industrialisation and their interaction or relationships with the industrial machinery. Although both movies emphasise the importance of the machine and the hard labour of the working class, they approach this differently. Lang’s “Metropolis” portrays the machine as an extension, or even part of the worker’s body (and vice versa). This is insinuated by the almost mechanical movement of the workers, and their close synchronised interaction with the machinery. An example of this is the scene where Freder is calibrating the one machine by physically moving the arms of the clock in sync with the flashing light sequence of the machine. Vertov’s “The Man with the Movie Camera” portrays man and the machinery as two separate entities, but with the common goal of productivity. Vertov uses a variation extreme close ups of the machinery and jump cuts to personify these machines. Thus placing equal importance on them with the workers who are also depicted operating the machinery.
Hence I believe that both films empathise with the working class and show a greater appreciation for the industrial machinery.
1.2. I believe that it is true that the movie camera does introduce us to unconscious optics. And this notion is applicable to both “Metropolis” and “The Man with the Movie Camera”. In “The Man with the Movie Camera”, Vertov makes great use of extreme close ups. The camera allows him zoom in everyday aspects of life that are normally viewed from a safe distance, such as machinery. These aspects are familiar to us but the camera adds another dimension to them. We all know how a locomotive or the gears in a machine works. But when we view them from an extreme angle a greater appreciation is developed for the complexity. In “Metropolis” the same is also true of the way Lang uses extreme close ups of the machinery in the city. It is arguable that these sort of extreme close ups subliminally suggest importance of the subject to the viewer. Thus changing the viewer’s perception of the subject and even creating a bias in favour of the suggested notion.
1.3. Oxford’s online dictionary defines capitalism as being, “an economic and political system in which a country’s trade and industry are controlled by private owners for profit, rather than by the state. The same source defines socialism as, “a political and economic theory of social organisation which advocates that the means of production, distribution and exchange should be owned or regulated by the community as a whole”. [Oxford Dictionary, 2009, [O]]
In Lang’s “Metropolis”, capitalism is represented by the “thinkers”, such as Johann Fredersen. These “thinkers” live high above the earth in luxurious modernist and Art Deco stylised buildings. These Art Deco buildings also represent capitalism, as Art Deco is believed to represent the bourgeois. Socialism is represented by the workers such as Maria. These workers live and work underground, in unsavoury conditions. Figuratively, the capitalist thinkers are referred to as the “head”, whilst the workers are referred to as the “hands”.
In Vertov’s “The Man with the Movie Camera”, capitalism is represented by the population who are shown riding leisurely in cars, or getting groomed and pampering themselves in Odessa’s beauty salons. Socialism on the other hand is represented by the machinery (which is presented as a character), and the workers who are shown hard work either maintaining the machinery, or interacting with it i.e. oiling the gears of the machinery or typing on a type writer. Figuratively capitalism is also represented in funeral scene where women are crying. And socialism is represented in the juxtaposing scene where a baby is being born.
I believe both films carry a message of hope in favour of socialism. In “Metropolis” this hope takes the form of Freder, Johann’s son who is referred to as the heart by the workers. Freder becomes the mediator between the “head” (capitalists) and the “hand” (socialists) and as a result of this common understanding and peace are achieved. Whereas in “The Man with the Movie Camera” the association of capitalism with the funeral insinuates that is a dying ideology or it is already dead. And the association of the birth of the baby with socialism suggests that a new ideology will be born and it will surpass capitalism.
2. I am going to analyse the themes found in Fritz Lang’s “Metropolis” and compare them to the themes in Ridley Scott’s “Blade Runner”.
I believe there are three main themes that are found in “Metropolis”. These are; the portrayal of the future city, the portrayal of social classes and the representation of the machine. I believe that these themes can also be found in “Blade Runner”.
Both “Metropolis” and “Blade Runner” are set in the future. Both films depict a dystopian society where the living conditions are miserable. In”Metropolis” the harsh living conditions seem only to apply to the workers whereas in “Blade Runner” the harsh living conditions seem to be experienced by everyone. On the surface the city in “Metropolis” is made up of Art Deco and modernist design inspired buildings. However, the city of the workers underground is cramped, uncomfortable, miserable and dark, which is similar to the portrayal of Los Angeles in the future in “Blade Runner”. Here although the city is lit up by electronic billboards and the large amount of vehicles hovering in the air or down on the busy streets, it still seems very dark and miserable. I find the city in “Blade Runner” to be chaotic when compared to the uniformity of the movement and dress of the workers in “Metropolis”. The Hong Kong inspired city in “Blade Runner” is plagued by a diversity of races, creeds, nationalities and species which make it even more chaotic.
Another theme that I believe is shared by the two films is the development of classes. In “Metropolis” the two classes are the thinkers (the head) and the workers (the hand). In “Blade Runner” the classes are divided into two. The one side being the humans and the other being the “replicants” who are genetically manufactured beings, created to perform hazardous and degrading work on Earth’s off world colonies. The replicants are similar to the workers (the hand), who are just used for labour. Whereas the humans, like the thinkers (the head) could be seen as the super class as they enjoy privileges and the freedom not known to the replicants and the workers.
I believe both films share similarities in their portrayal of the machine. In “Metropolis” the machine is portrayed as being part of the worker (or vice versa). In much simpler words they are one. This is suggested by machine-like movement of the workers and by their interaction with the machines. An example of this is shown in the scene where Freder becomes part of the machine when he has to calibrate it in sync with the flashing light sequence of the machine. In “Blade Runner” the machines are represented by the replicants which are actually half human, half machine, which is merely suggested in “Metropolis”. In both films the machinery is an aid to productivity and is portrayed as the means that sustains the world.
I have analysed and compared the themes found in “Metropolis” and “Blade Runner”.
Bibliography
Ask Oxford, 2009, Capitalism. [O]. Available:
http://www.askoxford.com/concise_oed/capitalism?view=uk
Accessed on 2009-03-06
Ask Oxford, 2009, Socialism. [O]. Available:
http://www.askoxford.com/concise_oed/socialism?view=uk
Accessed on 2009-03-06
Wiktionary, 2009. Industrialisation, [O]. Available:
http://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/industrialisation
Accessed on 2009-03-06
Filmography
Dziga Vertov, The Man with the Movie Camera, Soviet Union, 1929
Fritz Lang, Metropolis, Germany, 1929
Ridley Scott, Blade Runner, USA, 1982